Garden State Recovery Guide is operated by Treatment Outreach. We are not a medical provider, hospital, government agency, or emergency service. In a crisis, call or text 988. In an emergency, call 911. Who we are

If Insurance Denies Addiction Treatment in New Jersey: Appeals, Deadlines, and Records

A denial is not always the last word. In New Jersey, most people who are told a plan will not pay for addiction treatment have a right to a written explanation, an internal appeal with the plan, and, in many cases, an independent review by someone who does not work for the plan. Which steps and deadlines apply depends on what kind of plan you have: a New Jersey fully insured plan, NJ FamilyCare (Medicaid) through a health plan, or a self-funded employer plan. This guide explains each path and how to get the records you will need.

It is general information from State and federal sources, not legal, medical, or insurance advice. Deadlines are strict and your denial letter controls: follow the dates in the letter and ask the plan, the State, or an attorney if they differ from this page.

If you need help right now

  • Emergency or overdose: call 911. New Jersey law protects people who call for help in good faith during an overdose from arrest and prosecution for certain drug possession offenses.
  • Crisis: call or text 988 (free, confidential, 24/7).
  • ReachNJ, 1-844-732-2465: the State's free 24/7 addiction helpline, for referrals regardless of insurance or ability to pay.
  • Do not wait for an appeal to start safe care. If you are in treatment now and your plan says it will stop paying, ask the program and the plan right away about an expedited (urgent) appeal, which the sections below describe, and about continuing coverage while the appeal is pending.

First steps after a denial

  1. Get the denial in writing and read the reason. Plans must tell you why and how to appeal. Note the date you received it; most deadlines run from that date.
  2. Find out what kind of plan you have. Look at your ID card or call member services. New Jersey requires ID cards issued in the State to say whether coverage is fully insured or self-funded. NJ FamilyCare members have a health plan card (Aetna, Fidelis, Horizon, UnitedHealthcare, or Wellpoint).
  3. Ask your treatment program for help. Programs often have staff who handle approvals and appeals, and a letter from your treating clinician explaining why this level of care is needed carries weight. A program that appeals for you needs your written consent.
  4. Ask for an expedited appeal if delay could harm you. Urgent and continued-stay cases have much shorter review times in every path below.
  5. Keep a log of every call (date, name, reference number) and keep copies of every letter.
Your coverage Who handles complaints and external review Internal appeal deadline External review
Fully insured plan (employer or individual) issued in New Jersey, including plans bought through Get Covered NJ and the State Health Benefits Plan NJ Department of Banking and Insurance (DOBI) and its Independent Health Care Appeals Program (IHCAP) 180 days from receiving the denial Within 4 months of the final internal decision; independent physician review; binding on the plan
NJ FamilyCare through a managed care health plan NJ Department of Human Services (DMAHS), DOBI/IHCAP, and the Medicaid Fair Hearing process 60 calendar days from the date on the denial letter External appeal within 60 days of the internal decision; Medicaid Fair Hearing within 120 calendar days (for those eligible)
Self-funded employer plan (ERISA) U.S. Department of Labor (EBSA) At least 180 days under federal rules Federal external review process (request within 4 months)

Path 1: New Jersey fully insured plans

What New Jersey law says about addiction treatment coverage (P.L. 2017, c. 28)

New Jersey law P.L. 2017, c. 28, enacted February 15, 2017, sets special rules for substance use disorder (SUD) treatment in fully insured plans. DOBI Bulletin 17-05 explains how it works. For in-network care, and care obtained through an "in-plan exception," the law and bulletin provide:

  • Unlimited benefits for inpatient and outpatient SUD treatment at in-network facilities, with the care prescribed by a licensed physician, psychologist, or psychiatrist.
  • No prior authorization or other prospective utilization management for the first 180 days per plan year of inpatient and outpatient SUD treatment, when your physician, psychologist, or psychiatrist determines it is medically necessary. The facility must notify the plan of an admission and the initial treatment plan within 48 hours.
  • No concurrent or retrospective review of the first 28 days of an inpatient stay each plan year. After day 28, the plan may do concurrent review, no more often than every two weeks.
  • Intensive outpatient and partial hospitalization: no retrospective review of medical necessity for the first 28 days; after that, retrospective review is allowed.
  • Outpatient visits: not subject to concurrent or retrospective review of medical necessity or other utilization management during the first 180 days.
  • In-plan exception: if no in-network facility is immediately available, the plan must make an exception so you can be admitted within 24 hours.
  • After 180 days in a plan year, the plan may apply its own medical necessity review and prior authorization.
  • Medications: outpatient prescription drugs to treat SUD are covered when determined medically necessary by your physician, psychologist, or psychiatrist, without prior authorization or other prospective review.
  • Medical necessity tool: the law calls for an evidence-based, peer-reviewed clinical review tool to be designated through rulemaking by the Commissioner of Human Services in consultation with the Department of Health.
  • If the plan ends inpatient coverage after day 28: it must give you and your physician written notice within 24 hours of its decision and of your right to an expedited internal appeal, which the plan must decide within 24 hours. If it upholds the denial, you and your physician can file an expedited external appeal with the IHCAP, and the independent reviewer must decide within 24 hours. The law says you cannot be discharged or released until the internal and independent appeals are exhausted, and DOBI's bulletin says the stay is covered until the day after all appeals are exhausted, even if the plan's decision is upheld.

What the law does not cover. DOBI says the law applies to fully insured plans issued in New Jersey, the State Health Benefits Plan, and the School Employees Health Benefits Plan, for plans issued or renewed on or after May 16, 2017. Self-funded plans, Medicare, Medicaid, TRICARE, and out-of-state plans are not subject to it. Under a PPO or POS plan, if you choose an out-of-network provider voluntarily, those protections generally do not apply. If you are unsure, call the member services number on your card and ask whether the law applies, and write down the call reference number; DOBI says that if a carrier wrongly tells you it applies, the carrier must honor what it told you.

The three steps (utilization management appeals)

Under DOBI's rules for fully insured plans (N.J.A.C. 11:24A-3) and the State's consumer guidance:

  1. Stage 1 internal appeal (informal). You, or your provider with your consent, can appeal within 180 days of receiving the denial. The appeal does not have to be in writing, though a written request is wise. DOBI says the plan should decide as soon as possible, within 72 hours for urgent or emergency care, an admission, availability of care, or a continued stay, and generally within 10 days for other cases.
  2. Stage 2 internal appeal (formal; group plans). People in group plans have a second internal appeal, which must be requested within 180 days of the Stage 1 decision and decided within 20 business days (72 hours for urgent, admission, or continued-stay cases). People with individual plans have Stage 1 only and can go straight to external review.
  3. External appeal (IHCAP). After the internal appeal, you generally have four months from receiving the final internal decision to file with DOBI's contracted reviewer, Maximus Federal Services, at njihcap.maximus.com. An independent physician in the appropriate specialty reviews the case. The decision is due within 45 days, or within 48 hours for an expedited appeal (admission, continued stay while still in the facility, or a condition where waiting would seriously jeopardize life, health, or ability to regain maximum function). The decision binds the plan.

You can often skip ahead: DOBI says you can go directly to external review if the plan misses its appeal deadlines, waives its internal review, or if you request an expedited internal and expedited external appeal at the same time.

What to send to Maximus: the plan's initial denial, its internal appeal decision or decisions, your plan's summary of coverage (member handbook or certificate), a copy of the medical records and correspondence you want reviewed, any other helpful information, and, if a provider files for you, your signed consent and records release. Send copies, not originals. Information you send is shared with the plan.

Who cannot use IHCAP. DOBI says IHCAP does not review appeals from people covered by self-funded plans, Medicare or Medicare Advantage, or contracts delivered in another state; for services that are not covered under the plan's terms; or when the internal appeal has not been completed (unless an exception above applies).

Cost. DOBI's IHCAP page says carriers pay the cost of reviews. The State rule text we reviewed (N.J.A.C. 11:24A-3.6) lists a $25 filing fee, refundable if the plan's decision is reversed, waived for financial hardship (for example, a household member on Medicaid or NJ FamilyCare), and capped at $75 a year. Ask Maximus or DOBI whether any fee applies to your appeal before you file.

Contacts: Maximus Federal, NJ IHCAP, 888-866-6205 (njihcap.maximus.com; fax 585-425-5296; mail to 3750 Monroe Avenue, Suite 705, Pittsford, NY 14534); DOBI Office of Managed Care, 1-888-393-1062; DOBI Consumer Hotline for insurance complaints, 1-800-446-7467.

Path 2: NJ FamilyCare (Medicaid) managed care plans

If NJ FamilyCare, through one of the State's health plans, denies, reduces, or ends a service, the State describes this process. For the plans and their member lines, see our NJ FamilyCare guide.

  1. Internal appeal with your health plan. You, or your provider with your written consent, must ask within 60 calendar days of the date on the denial letter. There is no second internal stage. Federal Medicaid rules require plans to resolve a standard appeal within 30 calendar days and an expedited appeal within 72 hours.
  2. External appeal (IURO) through DOBI. If the plan upholds its denial, you can request independent review within 60 days of the internal appeal decision, using the External Appeal Application the plan sends with its decision, through Maximus. Expedited review (48 hours) is available for qualifying urgent cases.
  3. Medicaid Fair Hearing. For members who are eligible for one, you can request a hearing within 120 calendar days of the plan's internal appeal decision letter. You must receive the internal appeal result first. Send the completed request and a full copy of the decision letter to the DMAHS Fair Hearing Unit, P.O. Box 712, Trenton, NJ 08625-0712, fax 609-588-2435 (phone 609-588-2655). DMAHS sends the request to the Office of Administrative Law, which schedules the hearing. A 2026 DMAHS provider document says Medicaid Fair Hearings are not available for members in the NJ FamilyCare B, C, and D categories, so check your decision letter.
  4. Keeping services going during the appeal. If you are already receiving the service and want it to continue, you generally must ask on or before the last day of your current approval or within 10 calendar days of the denial letter, whichever is later. For a fair hearing, the State's provider FAQ says the request to continue benefits must be made in writing within 10 calendar days of the date of the plan's decision letter after the internal or external appeal, or by the last day of the prior approval, whichever is later. Do not miss this deadline even though other deadlines are longer.

Things specific to addiction treatment. Outpatient SUD counseling and medications for opioid use disorder, including methadone at an opioid treatment program, do not need prior approval under State rules. Intensive outpatient, partial care, residential levels, and inpatient detox do, and the program, not you, normally submits the request through the State's NJSAMS system. The State's materials say that if a plan misses its decision deadline (24 hours urgent, 7 days non-urgent), the request is approved administratively. For the first 60 days after January 1, 2027, plans cannot deny a complete first request for clinical reasons, and approvals active on January 1, 2027 stay active; details and caveats are on the FamilyCare guide.

The State appeal notice we rely on was published in 2017, and the 2026 DMAHS provider document is consistent with it. Plan letters should state the exact current steps, so follow the letter.

Path 3: Self-funded employer plans (ERISA)

Many large employers pay claims themselves (self-funded). These plans are governed by federal law, not by New Jersey insurance law, so P.L. 2017, c. 28 and DOBI's IHCAP generally do not apply to them. The federal claims rules (29 CFR 2560.503-1) and the Affordable Care Act's external review rules do.

  • Deadline to appeal: at least 180 days after you receive the denial for a group health plan.
  • How fast the plan must decide a claim: urgent care claims, as soon as possible and no later than 72 hours; other pre-service claims within 15 days (one 15-day extension allowed); post-service claims within 30 days (one extension).
  • How fast the plan must decide your appeal: urgent care, no later than 72 hours; pre-service, within 30 days for a plan with one level of appeal; post-service, within 60 days for a plan with one level of appeal. Plans with two levels have separate time limits for each.
  • What the denial letter must include: the specific reasons and plan provisions, any internal rule or guideline the plan relied on (or a statement that a copy will be provided free), an explanation of the clinical basis if it was a medical necessity denial (or a statement that it will be provided free), and a statement that you can get reasonable access to and copies of all documents relevant to your claim, free of charge.
  • External review: if your plan has no state process available to it, the federal process requires the plan to allow a request for external review within four months of the adverse determination or final internal decision, complete a preliminary review within five business days, assign an independent review organization, and have that organization decide within 45 days, or within 72 hours for expedited cases such as a continued stay or an admission.
  • Complaints: the U.S. Department of Labor's Employee Benefits Security Administration (EBSA) helps with problems with employer plans: 1-866-444-3272 or askebsa.dol.gov. Some plans choose to use the State's IHCAP voluntarily, so check your plan documents.

If your plan's remedies are exhausted, further options are legal matters. A lawyer or legal aid office can explain them.

Parity: is the plan treating addiction coverage differently?

The federal Mental Health Parity and Addiction Equity Act (MHPAEA) generally requires group health plans and insurers that cover mental health and SUD benefits to apply financial requirements and treatment limits no more restrictive than those they apply to medical and surgical benefits. That covers more than copays: it includes how a plan applies prior authorization, medical necessity criteria, network rules, and similar limits ("nonquantitative treatment limitations"). New Jersey's c. 28 adds the state-law protections above for fully insured plans, and its text says SUD benefits (other than the exceptions listed) are provided to the same extent as for any other medical condition.

Practical points:

  • You are entitled to ask. Under the federal parity statute (42 U.S.C. 300gg-26(a)(4)), a plan or insurer must, on request, give you the criteria it uses for medical necessity determinations for mental health and SUD benefits, and the reason for a denial. Ask for both in writing, along with the clinical guideline name and version the plan relied on (for example, whether it used the ASAM Criteria).
  • Where to complain: DOBI for fully insured plans; EBSA for self-funded employer plans.
  • Status of the federal parity regulations (as of November 2026). A 2024 final rule added new requirements, but in May 2025 the Departments of Labor, Health and Human Services, and the Treasury announced they would not enforce the parts of that rule that are new compared with the 2013 rule while a court challenge proceeds and for 18 months afterward. The Departments said the statute itself, including the requirement that plans document comparative analyses of their treatment limits, continues to apply. The Departments have said they plan to issue a revised proposed rule. This is changing, so treat what you read, including here, as a snapshot.

A plan that says "we only cover what is medically necessary" is allowed to review medical necessity, but you can ask whether it applies similar review to comparable medical or surgical care.

How to request records

From your plan:

  • The denial letter and, in writing, the specific reason, the plan provision relied on, and the clinical criteria or guideline used. Ask for the name and specialty of the reviewer.
  • The claim file. Fully insured plans must give you, free of charge, any new or additional evidence or rationale they rely on in an appeal (N.J.A.C. 11:24A-3.5); self-funded group plans must give you, on request and free of charge, reasonable access to and copies of all documents relevant to your claim (29 CFR 2560.503-1).
  • Your certificate of coverage or summary plan description, which describes covered levels of care, prior authorization rules, and appeal steps.

From your treatment program or doctor:

  • You have a right under HIPAA to inspect and get copies of your records. The program may require a written request and must act within 30 calendar days, with one 30-day extension if it explains why in writing. It may charge only a reasonable, cost-based fee for copying, supplies, and postage. Records from a substance use disorder program are also protected by 42 CFR Part 2, which allows a program to give you access to your own records. Disclosure to anyone else generally requires your written consent.
  • Ask for the assessment and level-of-care recommendation, treatment plan, progress notes, medication records, and any correspondence with the plan about authorization.
  • If your provider is appealing for you, sign their consent and records release form. The IHCAP uses a combined "Consent to Representation in Appeals of Utilization Management Determinations and Authorization for Release of Medical Records." A provider cannot require you to sign the consent as a condition of treatment, according to DOBI.

From the State (for NJ FamilyCare): your health plan's member services line can send your appeal file; the Fair Hearing Unit can answer questions about your hearing request.

What a strong appeal usually includes

  • The denial letter, your member ID, and the claim or authorization number.
  • A short statement of what you are asking for (for example, "continue intensive outpatient treatment for 30 more days").
  • A letter from your treating clinician explaining why this level of care is medically necessary, ideally referring to an accepted standard such as the ASAM Criteria, your diagnosis, your history, and the risks of a lower level of care.
  • Records that show why a lower level did not work or would not be safe.
  • A statement of any deadline that makes the appeal urgent.

No appeal is guaranteed to succeed, and we cannot predict an outcome.

Need help sorting through options?

If a partner facility is not a fit for you, we will say so and point you to other options, including ReachNJ and the programs listed above. You can always call any program directly.

Frequently asked questions

How long do I have to appeal an addiction treatment denial in New Jersey?

It depends on your plan. For a fully insured New Jersey plan, you have 180 days to file an internal appeal. For NJ FamilyCare through a health plan, it is 60 calendar days from the date on the denial letter. For a self-funded employer plan, federal rules require at least 180 days. Follow the deadline in your denial letter.

Can I get an independent review if my plan denies treatment?

Often yes. For fully insured plans and NJ FamilyCare, DOBI's Independent Health Care Appeals Program sends the case to an independent physician reviewer through Maximus. Fully insured plan members generally have four months after the final internal decision; NJ FamilyCare members have 60 days. Self-funded employer plans use a federal external review process.

What is an expedited appeal?

It is a faster review for urgent cases, such as a request for admission or continued stay or a situation where waiting could seriously harm your health. DOBI says expedited external appeals are decided within 48 hours, and under New Jersey's P.L. 2017, c. 28, a decision to end covered inpatient care after day 28 must be appealable within 24 hours.

Does New Jersey's addiction insurance law apply to my employer plan?

Only if it is a fully insured plan issued in New Jersey (or the State Health Benefits Plan or School Employees Health Benefits Plan). Self-funded plans, Medicare, Medicaid, TRICARE, and out-of-state plans are not subject to P.L. 2017, c. 28. Your ID card should say whether coverage is fully insured or self-funded.

Can I keep getting NJ FamilyCare treatment while I appeal?

You may be able to if you ask in time. The State says that if you are already receiving the service, you generally must ask on or before the last day of your current approval or within 10 calendar days of the denial letter, whichever is later.

What is a Medicaid Fair Hearing?

It is a hearing before the Office of Administrative Law for eligible NJ FamilyCare members who disagree with a health plan's decision after the internal appeal. Requests go to the DMAHS Fair Hearing Unit within 120 calendar days of the plan's internal appeal decision letter.

What is mental health and addiction parity?

The federal parity law generally requires plans that cover mental health and substance use disorder benefits not to apply tougher limits to them than to medical and surgical benefits. You can ask your plan for its medical necessity criteria and the reason for a denial. Federal enforcement of parts of the 2024 parity rule is paused, but the underlying law still applies.

How do I get my treatment records for an appeal?

Send your program or doctor a written request. Under HIPAA they must respond within 30 calendar days and may charge only a reasonable, cost-based fee. Substance use disorder program records also fall under 42 CFR Part 2, which allows you to access your own records. Your plan's claim file is available from the plan.

Is this legal advice?

No. This page is general information. For advice about your situation, contact DOBI, EBSA, the DMAHS Fair Hearing Unit, legal aid, or an attorney.

Sources

Last updated . Clinical review pending. This page is general information, not medical or legal advice. Legal summaries are pending counsel review. To report a correction, see Corrections.

Call (844) 797-7218 now